Consign with confidence

You keep the upside.We do the work.

Professional photography, strategic pricing, access to 90K+ live buyers, and transparent payouts.

Apply to consignSee how it works
80K+Live buyers
HigherSell-through vs. marketplaces
ItemizedTransparent payouts
CollectorFirst — always

Your payout, your tier

Slide to estimate. Tiers apply per item.
$500
$100$50,000
Your payout — hands-off
$375
You keep 75% · we do everything else
Line by lineSelling it yourselfConsign with the Vault
Platform & payment fees−$80 ~16%Covered by our commission
Shipping supplies sleeves · toploaders · team bags · mailers−$10$0 — we supply it
Postage & tracking, every sale−$15$0 — we pack & ship
Photography, listings, running shows, buyer messages~2 hrs of your time ≈ −$50 at $25/hrDone for you
Returns, disputes, lost packagesOn youWe handle it
Insight & recordsYour own spreadsheetItemized intake sheet · live listing status · sale-by-sale statement
Cash in hand$345after fees, costs & your time$375one shipment to us — done

Standard

Items under $1,000

Singles, mid-range slabs, and lots. 25% commission.

75%to you
Most popular

Premium

Items $1,000+

High-end slabs, chase holos, key vintage. 20% commission.

80%to you

Elite

Collections $25,000+

Dedicated handling, reserves, tailored fees. Talk to us.

Customterms
  • Ship once. One tracked box to Scottsdale; we handle every sale from there.
  • Full insight. Itemized spreadsheet at intake, updates as items list and sell.
  • Get paid. Payout 7 days after each sale clears.

Illustrative — typical marketplace fees ~16%, supplies ~2%, postage ~3%, time ≈ 1 hr per $250 sold. Terms confirmed in writing before intake.

Minimum lot $500 · payouts 7 days after each sale clears · reserves available on premium items.

The consignment process

1
ApplySend photos or a list through the form below. We confirm your lot qualifies ($500+ estimated), agree on terms and any reserves in writing, and lock in your commission tier before anything ships.
2
ShipShip to our Scottsdale intake with tracking; we send packing instructions and the address on approval. Every package is photographed on arrival and you get a same-day receipt confirmation with a card count.
3
We handle the restEach card is imaged front and back, variant-matched, and condition-noted. We set pricing off live comps, schedule your cards into the right shows, and run them in front of 90K+ buyers.
4
Get paidAs sales clear you get an itemized statement showing the sale price, commission, and your net. Payouts land within 7 days by ACH, Zelle, PayPal, or check — and soon you'll track it all in your Vault dashboard.
Your Vault dashboardComing soon

Watch every card sell.

Your Vault dashboard is on the way: what's listed, what sold, what you netted, and every payout — in real time. Until it launches, every consignor gets an itemized statement by email as sales clear.

Join early accessApply to consign

Why consign with us?

Massive buyer reach80K+ live-show followers.
Professional imagingEvery card, front and back.
Strategic pricingReserves and comps that maximize value.
Real-time trackingYour Vault dashboard.
Fast payoutsDirect to your account.

Ready to consign?

Apply now and let's get your cards in front of serious buyers. A person replies within one business day.

  • 1
    We reply within one business dayA real person confirms your lot qualifies and locks your commission tier in writing.
  • 2
    Ship once, trackedPacking guide and our Scottsdale address on approval. Every box is photographed the moment it lands.
  • 3
    Watch it sellItemized intake sheet, live listing status, and a statement after every sale — paid within 7 days of clearing.
Drop photos here or browse Best pieces first, slab labels legible. On your phone, tap to take photos. Up to 20 images.
Use Collectr? Share your collection link — it is the fastest way for us to price everything. Google Drive, Dropbox, iCloud and spreadsheet links work too.

No obligation until terms are agreed in writing.

Consignment FAQs

What are your consignment rates?

Tiered by item value: 25% on items under $1,000, 20% at $1,000 and up, and custom terms for Elite collections. No listing, photography, or hidden fees.

Is there a minimum?

Consignment works best from a $500 estimated lot value. Smaller lots are usually better as a direct buyout — we'll tell you which pays more.

How long until my cards sell?

Typically 7–21 days from intake to last sale, depending on lot size and show scheduling. Premium items are placed in the shows where they perform best.

When do I get paid?

Within 7 days after each sale clears — by ACH, Zelle, PayPal, or check — with an itemized statement showing sale price, commission, and net.

Can I set reserves?

Yes, on premium items by agreement. Unsold reserved items can be re-run, returned, or converted to a buyout.

Who pays for shipping?

Shipping to us is on you, up front, with any tracked carrier. Once your lot arrives we photograph the package, count the cards, and confirm receipt the same day.

Can I track my items?

You get an itemized intake sheet when your lot is verified, and a statement after every sale. A live consignor dashboard is coming with the customer portal.

Consign or sell outright — which is better?

Every Tier 2+ review includes both numbers. Consignment usually nets more on notable cards; buyouts win on speed and for bulk. Pick whichever fits.

View all FAQs →